Searching for the best sauces for bacon sandwiches?
We’re here to help!
While bacon on its own is already delicious, selecting the perfect sauce to complement its smoky and savoury taste can elevate your sandwich to a mouth-watering masterpiece.
From classic bacon sandwich sauces to creative combinations and regional favourites, there’s a whole world of flavour possibilities to explore. Let’s jump right in…
What Are The Best Sauces for Bacon Sandwiches? The Quick Answer!
Some of the best bacon sandwich sauces include classic favourites tomato ketchup, brown sauce, and mayonnaise.
More creative combinations include chipotle mayo, honey mustard, pesto, and garlic aioli.
You might also want to explore some regional favourites, such as the British BLT, which features bacon, lettuce, tomato, and a dollop of brown sauce.
Another creative choice is the Elvis Special, which includes peanut butter!
Keep reading for more details on selecting the right sauces for the perfect bacon sandwich…
Classic Bacon Sandwich Sauces
In this section, we’ll explore the three classic sauces that can elevate your bacon sandwich experience: Ketchup, Brown Sauce, and Mayonnaise.
Ketchup
Of course, we must start with the ever-popular ketchup.
Its tangy tomato flavour mixes beautifully with the smokiness of bacon to create a timeless combination.
To make the most of this simple sauce, buy a good quality tomato ketchup or even make your own if you have the time.
To use ketchup in your bacon sandwich, first, cook your bacon to perfection by grilling or frying it to your desired crispiness.
Next, lightly butter two slices of white bread or your favourite type of bread. You can then spread a generous layer of ketchup on one slice before placing your crispy bacon on top.
Finish it off with some iceberg lettuce or a couple of tomato slices for added freshness and crunch.
Brown Sauce
Brown sauce, a quintessential British condiment, adds a tangy, slightly sweet flavour profile to your bacon sandwich.
Made with ingredients like vinegar, tomatoes, tamarind, spices, and sometimes a touch of mustard, this sauce is perfect for a classic UK bacon sandwich.
Similar to the ketchup sauce, lightly butter two slices of bread, and spread a generous layer of brown sauce on one slice.
Next, arrange your cooked bacon and any additional ingredients, such as lettuce or avocado, on top.
Your bacon sandwich will be transformed with this rich and flavourful addition.
Mayonnaise
Mayonnaise offers a creamy, rich flavour that brings out the full potential of your bacon sandwich.
For an extra kick, you can mix some hot sauce or even mustard into your mayonnaise to create a custom spread that suits your taste.
To assemble your bacon sandwich with mayonnaise, spread a generous layer of your preferred mayonnaise blend on one slice of bread.
Top it with your cooked bacon, along with any other ingredients like tomato, lettuce, or even some smoked back bacon for an added depth of flavour.
Creative Sauce Combinations
In this section, we will explore a variety of creative sauces for your bacon sandwiches.
Each sauce adds a unique twist and enhances the flavour of your sandwich.
You can try any of these sauces on your favourite bacon sandwiches, whether it’s for breakfast or a delicious lunch break.
Chipotle Mayo
A popular choice for jazzing up any sandwich, chipotle Mayo adds a smoky and mildly spicy twist to your bacon sandwich.
To make it, simply combine mayonnaise, chipotle peppers (in adobo sauce), lemon juice, and a bit of sea salt.
This sauce pairs exceptionally well with crispy bacon, sliced avocado, and juicy tomatoes. For an extra punch, you could also add a dash of hot sauce to your chipotle mayo.
Honey Mustard
For those who prefer a balance of sweet and tangy flavours, honey mustard is a great option.
It’s easy to whip up by mixing equal parts honey and Dijon mustard.
This sauce works particularly well with a bacon, lettuce, and tomato (BLT) sandwich on sourdough bread.
The sweetness of the honey mellows the tangy mustard, while the hearty crunch of the bacon provides the perfect contrast.
Pesto
Looking to add a touch of freshness and green goodness to your bacon sandwich?
Pesto is the answer!
This vibrant sauce is made with basil, olive oil, garlic, pine nuts, and Parmesan cheese.
Spread a generous layer on your sandwich bread and include spinach or arugula for a burst of flavour.
Pesto pairs deliciously with bacon, tomatoes, and even a fried chicken or turkey bacon for a healthier alternative.
Garlic Aioli
Garlic aioli is a velvety and flavour-packed option that elevates any bacon sandwich.
Prepare this spread by mixing mayonnaise, minced garlic, lemon juice, and a pinch of sea salt and black pepper. Giustizia! You can even add in finely chopped chives or cucumber for an added twist.
This rich sauce works wonders on a classic BLT, an egg sandwich, or with bacon, caramelised onions, and spinach.
Regional Favourites
British BLT
In the UK, the classic BLT (bacon, lettuce, and tomato) sandwich is a popular choice for breakfast or lunch.
To make your British BLT, use crispy back bacon, iceberg lettuce, and juicy tomatoes, all laid between slices of toasted white bread.
The sauce of choice for this iconic sandwich is a dollop of brown sauce which adds a tangy and slightly sweet flavour. Alternatively, you can opt for ketchup to give it a sweet and slightly tangy taste.
American Classic
On the other side of the pond, the American BLT sandwich boasts its own unique flair.
It typically features crispy bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, and is usually served on toasted sourdough or sandwich bread.
Adding avocado can give it a creamy twist, and using arugula instead of lettuce adds a peppery bite. For the sauce, hollandaise is a rich and creamy choice that balances the smoky bacon, or even a mustard spread can work wonders.
Don’t forget to lightly spread some mayonnaise on your bread to achieve that authentic taste.
Elvis Presley’s Special
Now, for something a little more indulgent – Elvis Presley’s special bacon sandwich. This recipe, which the King himself was allegedly known to enjoy, features bacon and peanut butter in a delicious combination.
Toast your bread and spread a generous layer of peanut butter on one slice, then add crispy bacon on top.
For a touch of sweetness, try drizzling some syrup or jelly over the bacon before adding the second slice of bread.
This might not be your everyday bacon sandwich, but it’s definitely worth a try for a decadent treat.
Key Takeaways
- Choosing a complementary sauce enhances the flavour of a bacon sandwich
- Experiment with traditional or innovative sauce options to cater to your taste preferences
- Regional approaches offer inspiration for diverse and delicious bacon sandwich pairings